First Team |
| Stephen Faltay - Keystone |
| Danny Garcia - Lutheran West |
| Nolan Krumhansl - Fairview |
| Dawson Maiden - Keystone |
| Angel Ortiz - Lutheran West |
| Ben Osborne - Fairview |
| Matt Pettegrew - Columbia |
|
Second Team |
| Brian Barta - Columbia |
| Jared Bradford - Black River |
| Dylan Carson - Fairview |
| Martin Lowry - Fairview |
| Joel Pospisil - Brookside |
| Jared Swartz - Columbia |
| Charlie Yonts - Firelands |
|
Third Team |
| Zach Baldwin - Firelands |
| Vincent Del Rosario - Fairview |
| Henry Haas - Wellington |
| Mason Kabat - Buckeye |
| Alan Meriga - Fairview |
| Andrew Mohrbach - Brookside |
| Jacob Stahl - Buckeye |
|
