Second Team |
| Mason Besserer - Brookside |
| Conner Burke - Black River |
| Jake Case - Buckeye |
| Avery Cruz - Clearview |
| Trey DeCicco - Lutheran West |
| Cameron Emerick - Keystone |
| Timmy Hollander - Fairview |
| Gavin Horning - Oberlin |
| Nick Laposky - Wellington |
| Devon McLean - Black River |
| Mike Mileski - Keystone |
| Josiah Moon - Clearview |
| Jacob Mullins - Firelands |
| Tristen Peggs - Brooklyn |
| Tyler Robinson - Lutheran West |
| Jeremy Sassano - Fairview |
| Brandon Tanski - Brooklyn |
| Billy Turner - Columbia |
| Aaron Urban - Firelands |
| Collin Wright - Buckeye |
