First Team |
| Jake Albrecht - Lutheran West |
| Ben Champagne - Columbia |
| Carson Heidecker - Columbia |
| Damacio Martinez - Clearview |
| Nick Milluzzi (Pitcher) - Columbia |
| Kian Ortiz - Clearview |
| Jackson Schaum - Oberlin |
| John Smolik (Pitcher) - Lutheran West |
| Ryan Starks - Fairview |
| Ryan Szczepinski - Lutheran West |
| Aaron Wrost - Brooklyn |
|
Second Team |
| Avery Cruz - Clearview |
| Trey DeCicco - Lutheran West |
| Timmy Hollander - Fairview |
| Gavin Horning - Oberlin |
| Josiah Moon - Clearview |
| Tristen Peggs - Brooklyn |
| Tyler Robinson - Lutheran West |
| Jeremy Sassano - Fairview |
| Brandon Tanski - Brooklyn |
| Billy Turner - Columbia |
|
Honorable Mention -
Hunter Clawson - Oberlin;
Jared Greene - Brooklyn;
Martin Lowry - Fairview;
Julian Mendez - Clearview;
Owen Menge - Columbia;
Mike Montie - Lutheran West;
|
|
|
